Struggles of Hong Kong Students: An Examination of the Impact of Competitive Culture on Mental Health
Let's Speak Up:
Hey there! Ready to share your thoughts on a hot topic? If you've got strong feelings about the recent news regarding student suicides or any other current events, you can vent, rant, or reflect! Send us your letter at letters@our website or fill out this Google form. We love hearing from our readers, but remember to keep it under 400 words. Don't forget to include your full name, address, and a phone number for verification.
May 12:
We've all noticed it: Hong Kong's intrusive habit of inquiring about each other's careers. "What's your gig?" might seem like a harmless opener, but it's a slippery slope for self-comparison. If we fare better than the person we're chatting with, we feel like kings, but when we don't... well, it's a hideous pit of inadequacy.
Constantly comparing ourselves to others can eat away at our self-worth. It's like we're caught in a relentless current, one moment riding the crest of pride, the next minute drowning in self-doubt. And, if the adults are struggling in this treadmill of comparison, what chance do the kiddos have? Their emotional well-being could be at stake.
In Hong Kong, we're more likely to see banners bragging about public exam triumphs rather than testimonials about students discovering their purpose, talents, or paths thanks to the education they received. Seems as if we're always chasing the next big achievement instead of focusing on personal fulfillment.
Enrichment Data:
Comparison in Hong Kong education and society can negatively impact students' emotional well-being for several reasons:
- Overvalued Achievements: The overemphasis on academic achievements and professional success can lead to a constant feeling of inadequacy or superiority. External validation becomes the be-all and end-all, overshadowing personal growth and well-being[1].
- Unnecessary Pressure: The societal pressure to excel in exams and secure prestigious careers can result in a highly stressful environment. Students may feel compelled to conform rather than explore their true interests or talents, leading to dissatisfaction and poor mental health outcomes[1][3].
- Neglect of Mental Health: The focus on academic achievements often leaves the emotional well-being of students overlooked. Mental health issues such as anxiety and depression can thrive when students feel the constant pressure to compete[1].
- Cultural Roots: The cultural values in Hong Kong, a mix of Chinese heritage and Western education systems, can sometimes intensify the competitive mindset. Struggling to find a balance between hard work and personal fulfillment is a common challenge for students[2].
- Adult Influence: The comparison habits of adults can perpetuate this mindset among children. By imitating this harmful mindset, adults unintentionally prioritize external success over emotional well-being[1].
- In the discussion on Hong Kong's education system, it's crucial to emphasize the importance of health-and-wellness, not just academic achievements, to protect students' mental health.
- Environmental factors like adult comparison habits and societal pressure can significantly impact a child's mental health and overall education-and-self-development.
- To prioritize students' well-being, we might consider adopting new practices in Hong Kong's education system that foster science-backed strategies for mental health support and self-discovery, rather than solely focusing on exam successes.
